How it works

From the Cartesian plane to the atlas

Keeping the simplicity of current tests while raising their rigour and their fidelity to the real complexity of political positions.

The diagnosis

Shallow, non-orthogonal axes

The usual axes blend dimensions that ought to be treated independently. “Authority” confuses the reach of power with the scale at which it is exercised and with the source that legitimises it; “economy” confuses the desired arrangement with the method by which one intends to reach it. An anarcho-communist who accepts voluntary communes and one who means to impose collectivisation land on the same point of the plane — and they should not.

ORDVS separates the content of a position (what order is desirable?) from the method (by what path does it become legitimate?), and measures thirteen independent dimensions grouped in six layers.

The layers

I · Legitimacy

The source of political authority: transcendence, tradition, contract, consent or collective will.

Transcendent · TraditionalFoundationRational · Contractual
Individual consentBearer of authorityCollective will
II · Social ontology

The primary political subject — individual, family, community, nation, class — and the human nature it assumes.

IndividualPolitical subjectOrganic community
ConstrainedHuman naturePerfectible
III · Property & economy

Separates the substantive preference (the desired arrangement) from its character (voluntary or imposed).

PrivatePropertyCommon
Spontaneous orderCoordinationPlanning
VoluntaryCharacter of arrangementsImposed
IV · Culture & society

The relation to tradition and progress, and the degree of moral pluralism the public order admits.

TraditionMoral orientationProgress
Moral pluralityPluralismMoral unity
V · Institutions & scale

The preferred institutional scale — from local to universal — and the reach of coercive power.

LocalScaleCentral
MinimalReach of powerBroad
VI · Political epistemology

Where relevant knowledge resides and which criteria justify a political choice.

Dispersed · TacitKnowledgeTechnical · Centralisable
PrinciplesJustificationConsequences

The procedure

Broad first, specific later

The test begins with broad statements on fundamental premises (40 in the bank), on a five-point scale. Each answer shifts one or more dimensions with explicit weights; “don't know” does not score.

After the premises, the scores open up to four of 12 specific modules, chosen by trigger strength. Each module separates neighbouring traditions: lean towards a “minimal state” and you get statements that tell minarchist from anarcho-capitalist; lean towards common ownership and you get statements that tell councilist from Leninist. This is where rarely explored branches appear.

In the medium and long versions, a final reserve targets the dimensions where answers were most ambiguous or least covered.

Specific modules

Without the state · 6Minimal state and liberalism · 7Democratic socialism · 6Revolution · 7Faith and tradition · 6The Crown · 6Nation and authority · 7Community and subsidiarity · 6Ecology · 5Technique and development · 6Procedure and decision · 6Exit and institutional pluralism · 5

Versions

Short · 25 statements · ~5 min

20 premises · 1 module of 5

Medium · 50 statements · ~10 min

32 premises · 2 modules of 6 · 6 deepening

Long · 81 statements · ~18 min

40 premises · 4 modules of 7 · 13 deepening

The result

Affinity with each ideology, figure and era is the Euclidean distance across the thirteen dimensions, converted to a percentage. Positions of ideologies and figures are editorial interpretations, based on writings, documented policies and historical studies. The nemesis is the most distant figure.

Everything is calculated in the browser. No answer leaves your device; the share link carries only the thirteen scores.

Discover my profile →